Gilbert Keith Chesterton, a British novelist, says that “The traveler sees what he sees, the tourist see what he has come to see.” This idea is crucial in understanding E.M. Forster’s A Room with a View. In his work, E.M. Forster brilliantly represents contrastive ideologies on tourism through his character Lucy Honeychurch. Forster uses tourism as a motif to portray the transformation Lucy undergoes as a result of being exposed to authenticity, both in cultures and within herself.
When the story begins, the young English Lucy Honeychurch visits Florence with her set-in-her-ways cousin, Charlotte. Having lived a sheltered life, Lucy believes in the ideals of her proper and socially accepted mother which keeps her from truly immersing herself into the Florentine culture. While Forster alludes to the idea that Lucy desires adventure and authenticity, her words and mannerisms coincide with the beliefs of the strong-willed Charlotte, who feels a sense of responsibility for the innocent Lucy.
In the very opening scene, Charlotte verbalizes her disappointment with their rooms in Florence. Lucy chimes in by saying, “It might be London” (13). This immediately gives the reader the sense that neither of these girls are truly looking for the Italian culture. It is this idea of desiring “staged authenticity” that Urry speaks about in Consuming Places (140). While yes, they desire a different “authentic” view, the satire used by Forster in this opening scene shows their negative attitude about any discomfort or unplanned situation.
In a way, they are using this trip as an escape from their own lives, not as an opportunity to understand a new culture. Urry explains this idea of escape in the following way: “Places are chosen to be gazed upon because there is an anticipation, especially through day-dreaming and fantasy, of intense pleasures, either on a different scale or involving different senses from those customarily encountered” (Urry, Consuming Places, 132). They come to Italy to experience the relaxing culture of Italy, to escape the confinement of the English society, to be tourists. This goal of Charlotte and Lucy is more specifically characteristic of Urry’s collective tourist. “It is the presence of other tourists, people just like oneself, that is actually necessary for the success of such places which depend upon the collective tourist gaze” (Urry, Consuming Places, 138). Fortunately, through a series of events and encounters with others, Lucy’s time spent in Florence commences an awakening within her which allows her to experience a small amount of raw and authentic culture which foreshadows the future when she faces her raw self.
While in Italy, Lucy experiences several incidents which begin to help break away the naivete and innocence which have consumed her mind for so many years. The character of George Emerson is used as an instrument by Forster to expose Lucy to the true desires of her heart. Through chance encounters after the murder in the Loggia and in the field in Fiesole, Lucy has no choice but to come face-to-face with the realities of her life. The reality that she is living the life her mother and Charlotte have taught her, the life of the simple tourist in a sense—of the person who travels to see what she has expected to see, not to experience life, or another city in its true essence.
Buzard talks about the four keys to achieving authenticity. “I will focus here on four such motifs, which may be called stillness, non-utility, saturation, and picturesqueness” (Buzard, The Beaten Track,177). The most prominent of these motifs in relation to Lucy’s evolution is saturation. Buzard continues to say, “The setting best rewarding travelers is so densely ‘saturated’ in historic and emotional significance that each step of the ground seems able to evoke the most powerful feelings; when ‘truly sensitive’ travelers stand upon this ground, they feel to the fullest extent of their capacity” (Buzard, The Beaten Track, 185). The reason her meetings with George had such a great impact is because it was Lucy’s first true saturation. The murder in the Loggia leaves Lucy constantly obsessed by her emotions about this event. As Buzard suggests, she cannot go a single step in the city without focusing on these ideas. She is filled with the emotion and history of the events that had previously occurred. Lucy also experiences this side of authenticity during her scene with George in the violet field. Each flower in the field reminds her of beauty and she becomes completely aware of her aloneness with George.
Lucy immediately suppresses the realities she faces in Italy, in part due to her social status, and part due to her ignorance of what has occurred. After she shares a kiss with George in the violet field, Charlotte instantly asks, “What is to be done?” (113). Nearly all of the people in Lucy’s life have this mindset of perfection and of status. She aims to please those she loves and therefore follows their lead when choosing how to reflect upon past situations and occurrences in her life. By Charlotte asking this question so quickly, Lucy avoided processing the event in her own mind. She simply looked at it as a problem which needed a solution instead of letting herself feel the emotions linked with the kiss. In the same way, Charlotte and Lucy looked at their lodging as a problem as oppose to truly allowing it to be an opportunity to experience and understand something outside of their own familiarity.
It is not until after two important conversations with the Emersons occur that Lucy begins to liberate her locked-up emotions. After another kiss is shared with George, she has a discussion with him that leaves her perplexed. In response to the kiss, George says, “I don’t apologize. But it has frightened you, and you may not have noticed that I love you” (155). His honesty with Lucy in a way is a mirror for her to see her true self. Forster writes, “But, once in the open air, she paused. Some emotion—pity, terror, love, but the emotion was strong—seized her, and she was aware of autumn” (156). Lucy was beginning to see her authentic self, and while it scared her and made her uncomfortable, just as the authentic Florence did when they first arrived to their pension, she took action upon her feelings. For the first time, she took time to reflect, and to free herself from the control Cecil Vyse had over her. She did not fully understand why, and in several ways was continuing to deceive herself about why she broke off her engagement, but she unconsciously felt a sense of relief because she was that much closer to her genuine happiness.
At the conclusion of the novel, Lucy has a life-altering conversation with Mr. Emerson. He shares with her the need for love and passion to be united with one’s actions in order to achieve true happiness. Mr. Emerson says “We fight for more than Love or Pleasure: there is Truth. Truth counts, Truth does count” (191). Forster reflects on the conversation in the following passage: “She ‘never exactly understood,’ she would say in after years, ‘how he managed to strengthen her. It was as if he had made her see the whole of everything at once’” (191). This line is crucial to understand Forster’s tourism motif. Not only does this conversation with Mr. Emerson open Lucy to herself, it also opens her to the world in a broader aspect.
During her entire life, Lucy feared the unknown and discomfort. She lived under the umbrella of her social status and inherited the fears of those around her. By allowing herself to embrace her love for George, she gained confidence and became an individual, willing to take on the unknown, instead of a Honeychurch or a Vyse. She was able to accept someone of a different class than herself, and by allowing herself to be stripped down of her preconceived notions about other cultures and societies, she was able to truly be saturated. She learned to not only accept, but to cherish something authentic.
Cecil says it perfectly when he recaps his thoughts about Lucy after her return from Italy. “That day she had seemed a typical tourist—shrill, crude, and gaunt with travel. But Italy worked some marvel in her. It gave her light, and –which he held more precious—it gave her shadow” (83). And while Cecil was able to notice a change at this moment, the true change for Lucy was to come later, after her saturation and acceptance of another culture. She begins the story as a tourist, searching for and thinking about what others suggest to her. She only appreciates those things which give her a sense of comfort and security. The story ends with Lucy as a traveler—original in thought, and searching for the truth and authenticity of life and others.
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Sunday, November 29, 2009
Fornasier Luigi
When people hear the words “Murano glass” their minds instantly jumps to Venice, Italy. If this glass is famous all around the world, then why are tourists given such a false reality about the artistic trade when they wander through the streets of Venice? The pieces that they are purchasing are advertised as authentic, when in reality they are far from it. They often times have no relation to the island of Murano in general. Having now lived in Venice for nearly two months, I have been exposed to my fair share of Murano glass (real and imitations). I’ve seen it all--bracelets, bottles, plates, chandeliers, you name it. It has never meant very much to me, and it always seemed like just another thing to keep the tourist industry thriving. Today I am grateful to say that my opinion about all of that has changed. I was given the opportunity to go with a group of about seven or eight to a true Murano glass factory. We received a private tour of Fornasier Luigi and we were also able to see the master glass blower hard at work producing the base for one of his famous, world-renowned chandeliers.
In a way, the feelings I have about this industry remind me of Ruskin. He respected the Gothic style because of its ability to exemplify the artistic hand. He embraced the individuality and uniqueness even when others could not see the beauty in it. Ruskin describes this idea by saying, “Men were not intended to work with the accuracy of tools, to be precise and perfect in all their actions. If you will have that precision out of them, and make their fingers measure degrees like cogwheels, and their arms strike curves like compasses, you must unhumanize them” (The Genius of John Ruskin, 177). In the same way, the industry now prominently contains perfectly shaped pieces created by inhuman means in a factory instead of the beautiful and unique pieces that were once praised. The mass-produced pieces cannot embody the emotion and personality of each of the pieces that Fornasier Luigi produces. It dehumanized the art.
I now walk past the “Murano” stands and have an almost disgusted feeling within me. It’s like another great piece of Venice has been distorted into a keychain. In addition to the misleading postcard, the tourist now has the ability to take home a false work of art and history by purchasing a 2 Euro pair of earrings. Yes, authentic Murano glass is expensive, but this is due to the number of hours it takes to create a beautiful, hand-made piece. It shouldn’t be taken advantage of in the way that it is. I guess that’s what happens when tourists arrive. They always want to take a piece of the city with them in order to remember, and this is a more economical way for them to do that.
Our tour began by watching glass blowing and ended when a guide shared with us some of the thoughts and perspectives of the family who owns this business. Both aspects of the tour opened my mind to new ideas that I had been previously unaware of. In her work, On Longing, Stewart states that “[The kitsch object’s] expendability is the expendability of all consumer goods, their dependence upon novelty as the replacement of use value and craftsmanship” (On Longing, 168). This is the truth for the Murano glass that fills Venice. These kitsch objects, such as bottle toppers, strive to have beautiful designs and unique colors in order to sell themselves. The prices become competitive, and people only want the objects because the world tells them that they are supposed to when they come to Venice. The truth is, as Stewart states, that the craftsmanship and use value are much deeper than these imitations can represent. Something about watching the sweat cascade down the glass blower’s face while he worked with the hot, malleable glass showed me just how much the imitation glass misses the true point of this art form. In a way, I find it degrading to the families who truly and passionately work in this field.
This particular family has a grand history in Venice. They were responsible for the “Rezzonico” style chandeliers which were covered in ornate decoration (particularly beautifully colored flowers), and were given special treatment in the past by Doges. According to our guide, they were given a private gondolier, they were allowed to have relationships with the daughters of the doges, and they were allowed to travel within the Veneto region to promote their work. The business has been in their hands for many years, and each person who is trained is passionate about what he or she does. They have recently been refusing requests for the “Rezzonico” style in order to pursue a more modern style. This is due to the fact that the master glass blower at the current time wants to remain passionate about his work and wants to switch the style in order to stay fully interested. How striking it was to hear this! In no way, shape, or form, do the “made in China” pendants sold on the streets embody this. They do not even come close to showing the handwork and hours of effort that go into each authentic piece. This art that used to be highly respected has been demeaned to a kitsch, mass-produced industry.
In a way, the feelings I have about this industry remind me of Ruskin. He respected the Gothic style because of its ability to exemplify the artistic hand. He embraced the individuality and uniqueness even when others could not see the beauty in it. Ruskin describes this idea by saying, “Men were not intended to work with the accuracy of tools, to be precise and perfect in all their actions. If you will have that precision out of them, and make their fingers measure degrees like cogwheels, and their arms strike curves like compasses, you must unhumanize them” (The Genius of John Ruskin, 177). In the same way, the industry now prominently contains perfectly shaped pieces created by inhuman means in a factory instead of the beautiful and unique pieces that were once praised. The mass-produced pieces cannot embody the emotion and personality of each of the pieces that Fornasier Luigi produces. It dehumanized the art.
I now walk past the “Murano” stands and have an almost disgusted feeling within me. It’s like another great piece of Venice has been distorted into a keychain. In addition to the misleading postcard, the tourist now has the ability to take home a false work of art and history by purchasing a 2 Euro pair of earrings. Yes, authentic Murano glass is expensive, but this is due to the number of hours it takes to create a beautiful, hand-made piece. It shouldn’t be taken advantage of in the way that it is. I guess that’s what happens when tourists arrive. They always want to take a piece of the city with them in order to remember, and this is a more economical way for them to do that.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Longing for the Unique
Venice is a city capable of evoking numerous thoughts and emotions. Each traveler that stumbles upon this city possesses a preconceived idea about what the culture and experiences of Venice will entail. Venice is a unique place. The culture, the construction of the city, the priceless artwork, the beautiful churches, and many other factors can be found in no other city in the world. Travelers flock to the city with the desire to live out one of the well-known myths of the city. Some people may travel to Venice to fulfill their longing to experience history or the arts while others may come for liberation, but any way it is looked at, the base component is the yearning to experience the unique.
One of the most common myths of Venice is the idea that Venice freezes the past. One of the most attractive attributes of the city to tourists, guide books, and the media is its ability to preserve the historical aspects of its government, architecture, and construction in general. While the city continues on in modern days, it thrives on both the preservation of the past and on its ability to decay in a beautiful manner. The tourism industry focuses on the old, and the architecture itself (even when remodeled), represents a mixture of distinguishable architectural styles from past centuries. Every calle in Venice incorporates aspects of Gothic and Renaissance architecture, and a person does not need to walk too far in order to stumble upon Baroque, Byzantine, or Palladian architecture. Part of this of course is the city’s inability to logistically support sky scrapers, but that is not the only reason the city refrains from modernizing the construction. It also refuses to modernize in order to allow the decline of the city to portray an image of frailty and helplessness, similar to that of a damsel in distress. Byron explains the beauty found in this fragility in his work With Byron in Italy. He writes, “Perchance even dearer in her day of woe / Than when she was a boast, a marvel, and a show” (With Byron in Italy, 64).
Perhaps the traveler is not passionate about the history Venice represents. Maybe skyscrapers, roads, or artistic expression are more enticing. Whether it be Lord Byron, Shelley, Titian, Tintoretto, or Vivaldi, the tourist can find the essence of the arts within the Venetian culture. It is possible to saunter into the Frari and locate a piece of art by Bellini, or to walk into the Academia and see the priceless Vitruvian Man by Leonardo DaVinci. It is not the collection of artwork in itself that creates the artistic culture in Venice. The longing can be correlated with the inspiration that arose from the beauty and uniqueness of Venice. Many have said the famous quote, “see Venice and die”. Many artists have found their passion within this city and have felt that they have achieved everything there is in life by expressing themselves here. Many tourists long to uncover the same inspiration, the same beauty, and the same passion that so many others have experienced before them.
Another great myth of Venice is the idea of Venice as a carnival city. Famous for its sexual debauchery, cortisans, and the masturbatory fantasies that it creates, Venice has a reputation for allowing anyone to create a secret identity. It allows people to travel here with the ability to put on a mask, both literally and figuratively. Of course during the week-long Carnival (which used to last much longer), participants of the festivities don masks in order to live out their fantasies while remaining anonymous. In many ways though, a physical mask is not required, and the carnival lasts year round. Casanova, Lord Byron, and Veronica Franco are only three examples of people who took advantage of the sexual liberation provided by Venice, but it is a common practice throughout. Represented not only in art and poetry, but in lifestyles too, Venice is one place on earth where sexuality is not only accepted, but embraced. Veronica Franco publicly writes “I will show you my heart open in my breast, / once you no longer hide yours from me, / and my delight will be to please you” (Poems in Terza Rima lines 46-48). This idea of sexuality may be prevalent in other societies, but the openness and acceptability is a signature feature of Venice. It is a city known as being an escape from reality where people have the ability to let loose and live out their fantasies without repercussions.
Whatever longing the traveler may possess deep within, Venice fulfills those desires in a way that only Venice can. History, art, liberation, among many other things can all be found in the heart of this unique land situated in a lagoon. Whether it is the obvious distinct features such as canals and the lack of cars, or some of the more hidden gems of Venice such as its inspiration and decay, Venice is a city that is longed for by many. This longing comes from uniqueness and the fact that no other place compares to Venice. It is not possible to travel to another similar sized city and have a similar experience. “Venice can be compared only with itself” (Goethe, Italian Journey, 59). Stewart writes that “The silence of the photograph, its promise of visual intimacy at the expense of the other senses (its glossy surface reflecting us back and refusing us penetration), makes the eruption of that narrative, the telling of its story, all the more poignant” (On Longing, 138). This is particularly true for photographs of Venice. A city unique in itself, which writes fascinating narratives that cannot possibly be captured on film, is left to be spoken about by those whom possess these photographs, those whose longings have been fulfilled.
One of the most common myths of Venice is the idea that Venice freezes the past. One of the most attractive attributes of the city to tourists, guide books, and the media is its ability to preserve the historical aspects of its government, architecture, and construction in general. While the city continues on in modern days, it thrives on both the preservation of the past and on its ability to decay in a beautiful manner. The tourism industry focuses on the old, and the architecture itself (even when remodeled), represents a mixture of distinguishable architectural styles from past centuries. Every calle in Venice incorporates aspects of Gothic and Renaissance architecture, and a person does not need to walk too far in order to stumble upon Baroque, Byzantine, or Palladian architecture. Part of this of course is the city’s inability to logistically support sky scrapers, but that is not the only reason the city refrains from modernizing the construction. It also refuses to modernize in order to allow the decline of the city to portray an image of frailty and helplessness, similar to that of a damsel in distress. Byron explains the beauty found in this fragility in his work With Byron in Italy. He writes, “Perchance even dearer in her day of woe / Than when she was a boast, a marvel, and a show” (With Byron in Italy, 64).
Perhaps the traveler is not passionate about the history Venice represents. Maybe skyscrapers, roads, or artistic expression are more enticing. Whether it be Lord Byron, Shelley, Titian, Tintoretto, or Vivaldi, the tourist can find the essence of the arts within the Venetian culture. It is possible to saunter into the Frari and locate a piece of art by Bellini, or to walk into the Academia and see the priceless Vitruvian Man by Leonardo DaVinci. It is not the collection of artwork in itself that creates the artistic culture in Venice. The longing can be correlated with the inspiration that arose from the beauty and uniqueness of Venice. Many have said the famous quote, “see Venice and die”. Many artists have found their passion within this city and have felt that they have achieved everything there is in life by expressing themselves here. Many tourists long to uncover the same inspiration, the same beauty, and the same passion that so many others have experienced before them.
Another great myth of Venice is the idea of Venice as a carnival city. Famous for its sexual debauchery, cortisans, and the masturbatory fantasies that it creates, Venice has a reputation for allowing anyone to create a secret identity. It allows people to travel here with the ability to put on a mask, both literally and figuratively. Of course during the week-long Carnival (which used to last much longer), participants of the festivities don masks in order to live out their fantasies while remaining anonymous. In many ways though, a physical mask is not required, and the carnival lasts year round. Casanova, Lord Byron, and Veronica Franco are only three examples of people who took advantage of the sexual liberation provided by Venice, but it is a common practice throughout. Represented not only in art and poetry, but in lifestyles too, Venice is one place on earth where sexuality is not only accepted, but embraced. Veronica Franco publicly writes “I will show you my heart open in my breast, / once you no longer hide yours from me, / and my delight will be to please you” (Poems in Terza Rima lines 46-48). This idea of sexuality may be prevalent in other societies, but the openness and acceptability is a signature feature of Venice. It is a city known as being an escape from reality where people have the ability to let loose and live out their fantasies without repercussions.
Whatever longing the traveler may possess deep within, Venice fulfills those desires in a way that only Venice can. History, art, liberation, among many other things can all be found in the heart of this unique land situated in a lagoon. Whether it is the obvious distinct features such as canals and the lack of cars, or some of the more hidden gems of Venice such as its inspiration and decay, Venice is a city that is longed for by many. This longing comes from uniqueness and the fact that no other place compares to Venice. It is not possible to travel to another similar sized city and have a similar experience. “Venice can be compared only with itself” (Goethe, Italian Journey, 59). Stewart writes that “The silence of the photograph, its promise of visual intimacy at the expense of the other senses (its glossy surface reflecting us back and refusing us penetration), makes the eruption of that narrative, the telling of its story, all the more poignant” (On Longing, 138). This is particularly true for photographs of Venice. A city unique in itself, which writes fascinating narratives that cannot possibly be captured on film, is left to be spoken about by those whom possess these photographs, those whose longings have been fulfilled.
Monday, November 16, 2009
Avignon
This town was filled with beautiful gardens, churches, and old palaces. We were left to roam around on our own and to just take in the beautiful scenery. We climbed several hills and towers, and could easily go two hours without seeing another human being. It was peaceful. I felt less anxious than in other towns, and how nice it was to experience a different kind of traveling. For one of the first times since I have been in Europe, I felt like a romantic tourist versus a collective tourist. Urry reflects on the romantic tourist in the following passage: “Those who value solitude and the romantic tourist gaze do not see this as merely one way of regarding nature. They consider it as ‘authentic’, as real” (Urry, Consuming Places, 138).
The whole weekend was an adventure. We were left to think, to wander, and to take on the city. It was such a desirable experience. I needed the break from the museum lines, the stereotypical sights to see, and the crowds of people. Avignon was the perfect place for taking that break! I guess I shouldn’t continue to share my love for this city though, because as Urry says, once the word is out, the crowds will start coming!
Wednesday, November 11, 2009
Laurea
Walking down the streets of a northern Italian town, it is not out of the ordinary to stumble across a half-naked person being serenaded by a small group of close friends and family members. This common occurrence is a typical graduation ceremony which takes place when a student has completed the equivalent of a Master’s degree in America. The Italian’s refer to this as the Laurea. The name comes from the Laurea which used to be the highest degree one could achieve in Italy. It included four to six years of coursework and the completion of a thesis. These celebrations now occur once the student has completed their final exam and walked out of the classroom door for the last time. This celebration represents more than just the completion of schoolwork. The amount of work that friends and family put into the traditions, as well as the experiences they share with the new graduate, all represent the personal relationships and accomplishments of the former student.. Each individual’s celebration is unique, but they each fulfill certain aspects and customs.
The most crucial element of this Italian custom is the scroll, or il papiro in Italian. For each graduate, a three foot by five foot poster is created to be read and displayed throughout their university and their hometown. Each papiro contains a rhyming narrative which describes the graduate’s life. It normally begins with birth and contains childhood memories, embarrassing moments, and any other bits of information the creator desires to include. The papiro also displays some sort of picture whether it is a photograph or a caricature. Commonly the body is an illustration while the head is sometimes a genuine photograph. The purpose of the drawing is to give a humorous or embarrassing representation to the individual. Bodies are often drawn in an exaggerated sexual style containing overly emphasized body parts, risqué clothing, and bodily fluids among other things. Once these scrolls are created they are displayed on a wall at the university, a copy is often taken home to be hung by the parents in their home or perhaps a family business, and another copy is saved for the celebration.
Upon completion of the exam, the graduate is met by fellow classmates, friends, and family, and is given an interesting appearance. An essay entitled Literacy Practice in the Piazza: An Analysis of Italian Graduation Scrolls explains that, “graduates are then stripped to either a bathing suit or underwear and put in various costumes such as cross-gender clothing, garbage bags, and animal suits” (Molè, Texas Linguistic Forum, 2004). In addition to the clothing, students are adorned with duct tape, eggs, face paint, or other substances. The final piece of the puzzle is to be crowned with a laurel wreath, the general symbol for graduation, complete with a red bow. Once in costume, the graduate is presented with their scroll.
The next step is the reading of the scroll. Walking around Padua and Venice I have seen this done several times. In the majority of instances the graduate stands on top of a park bench, a bridge, or another elevated surface and reads aloud the narrative created for them. According to Molè again, the scrolls are written in a mixture of standard Italian and the Veneto dialect. Because of this, it is often difficult for the graduate to audibly read the papiro. While commonly spoken, the dialect is not often written. Throughout schooling the students are taught to read and write in the classic Italian. The tradition is that when a word is mispronounced or stumbled upon it is suggested that the reader take a drink of wine. In many instances, the graduate is quite intoxicated by the end of the narrative. After the reading of the scroll the graduate may be asked to complete other tasks, which are chosen by the friends and family involved, and are often absurd tasks such as pouring milk on themselves.
Throughout the celebration and after the other traditions have taken place, a common song is sung numerous times while the graduate walks through a town center, down a street, or into a highly public area. The words to the song are as follows: “Dottore, dottore, dottore nel buso del cul, vaffancul, vaffancul”. Translated, this expression is incredibly vulgar and in instances other than graduation, the expressions used would not be socially acceptable. However, the tune is rather catchy, and can stick in your head for several hours. The simple fact that the majority of these traditions occur speaks a great deal about the Italian culture in general. Any given day in Italy, I can be made aware of just how relaxed the Italian way of life is. Whether it be the break in the middle of the day when shops close so that the workers have an opportunity to rest at home, the lack of pressure waiters put on customers to leave, or the simple lack of promptness Italians have when meeting up with one another, the culture is easy going. Quite possibly the Laurea only occurs in northern Italy because it is one location where the culture allows for the occasional immodest clothing and vulgar tunes.
After all festivities, the graduate returns to their normal clothing and often enjoys the company of their friends and family at a local caffè or restaurant. Confetti is often thrown and a graduation gift of wrapped almonds is sometimes passed out as a parting gift to guests.
While many cultures partake in graduation celebrations, the Italian festivities are outrageous and extremely public. The whole concept is similar to the Venetian Carnevale which Casanova mentions in his memoirs. “It was during the Carnival of 1745, after midnight; we were, all the eight of us, rambling about together with our masks on, in quest of some new sort of mischief to amuse us.” Casanova associates this idea of tomfoolery with Carnevale. Carnevale is also commonly associated with the ability to escape reality and create a temporary identity. In the same way, the Laurea allows the student to be temporarily out of character in order to celebrate their liberation from schooling. It is a chance for chaos to ensue in a controlled situation and amount of time. The most rebellious and rambunctious Carnevale attendees are those who tend to be the more conservative ones, so it should be no surprise that the students earning some of the highest degrees are the same half naked students stumbling down the streets of northern Italy.
The most crucial element of this Italian custom is the scroll, or il papiro in Italian. For each graduate, a three foot by five foot poster is created to be read and displayed throughout their university and their hometown. Each papiro contains a rhyming narrative which describes the graduate’s life. It normally begins with birth and contains childhood memories, embarrassing moments, and any other bits of information the creator desires to include. The papiro also displays some sort of picture whether it is a photograph or a caricature. Commonly the body is an illustration while the head is sometimes a genuine photograph. The purpose of the drawing is to give a humorous or embarrassing representation to the individual. Bodies are often drawn in an exaggerated sexual style containing overly emphasized body parts, risqué clothing, and bodily fluids among other things. Once these scrolls are created they are displayed on a wall at the university, a copy is often taken home to be hung by the parents in their home or perhaps a family business, and another copy is saved for the celebration.
Upon completion of the exam, the graduate is met by fellow classmates, friends, and family, and is given an interesting appearance. An essay entitled Literacy Practice in the Piazza: An Analysis of Italian Graduation Scrolls explains that, “graduates are then stripped to either a bathing suit or underwear and put in various costumes such as cross-gender clothing, garbage bags, and animal suits” (Molè, Texas Linguistic Forum, 2004). In addition to the clothing, students are adorned with duct tape, eggs, face paint, or other substances. The final piece of the puzzle is to be crowned with a laurel wreath, the general symbol for graduation, complete with a red bow. Once in costume, the graduate is presented with their scroll.
The next step is the reading of the scroll. Walking around Padua and Venice I have seen this done several times. In the majority of instances the graduate stands on top of a park bench, a bridge, or another elevated surface and reads aloud the narrative created for them. According to Molè again, the scrolls are written in a mixture of standard Italian and the Veneto dialect. Because of this, it is often difficult for the graduate to audibly read the papiro. While commonly spoken, the dialect is not often written. Throughout schooling the students are taught to read and write in the classic Italian. The tradition is that when a word is mispronounced or stumbled upon it is suggested that the reader take a drink of wine. In many instances, the graduate is quite intoxicated by the end of the narrative. After the reading of the scroll the graduate may be asked to complete other tasks, which are chosen by the friends and family involved, and are often absurd tasks such as pouring milk on themselves.
Throughout the celebration and after the other traditions have taken place, a common song is sung numerous times while the graduate walks through a town center, down a street, or into a highly public area. The words to the song are as follows: “Dottore, dottore, dottore nel buso del cul, vaffancul, vaffancul”. Translated, this expression is incredibly vulgar and in instances other than graduation, the expressions used would not be socially acceptable. However, the tune is rather catchy, and can stick in your head for several hours. The simple fact that the majority of these traditions occur speaks a great deal about the Italian culture in general. Any given day in Italy, I can be made aware of just how relaxed the Italian way of life is. Whether it be the break in the middle of the day when shops close so that the workers have an opportunity to rest at home, the lack of pressure waiters put on customers to leave, or the simple lack of promptness Italians have when meeting up with one another, the culture is easy going. Quite possibly the Laurea only occurs in northern Italy because it is one location where the culture allows for the occasional immodest clothing and vulgar tunes.
After all festivities, the graduate returns to their normal clothing and often enjoys the company of their friends and family at a local caffè or restaurant. Confetti is often thrown and a graduation gift of wrapped almonds is sometimes passed out as a parting gift to guests.
While many cultures partake in graduation celebrations, the Italian festivities are outrageous and extremely public. The whole concept is similar to the Venetian Carnevale which Casanova mentions in his memoirs. “It was during the Carnival of 1745, after midnight; we were, all the eight of us, rambling about together with our masks on, in quest of some new sort of mischief to amuse us.” Casanova associates this idea of tomfoolery with Carnevale. Carnevale is also commonly associated with the ability to escape reality and create a temporary identity. In the same way, the Laurea allows the student to be temporarily out of character in order to celebrate their liberation from schooling. It is a chance for chaos to ensue in a controlled situation and amount of time. The most rebellious and rambunctious Carnevale attendees are those who tend to be the more conservative ones, so it should be no surprise that the students earning some of the highest degrees are the same half naked students stumbling down the streets of northern Italy.
Monday, November 9, 2009
Breaking down the Language Barrier
Having now been in Europe for a month and a half, I am starting to understand the true importance of language. It may irritate the locals, cause some inconveniences, or even lead me to order something grotesque from the menu, but in all reality, it has been possible to get through my travels without ever having to stray away from the English language which I speak. I can get by with little to no problems. Perhaps it is because the United States is a world superpower as Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri discuss in their work, Empire. They speak about this idea that the United States not only affects its own territories, but also influences other areas of the earth. In this instance, the influence is reflected through language. Many people in other countries speak English, and I have been able to travel comfortably without having studied a European language. Through Germany, Austria, and Italy, I was always able to find several people to communicate with. With that said, I especially noticed this week how much richer my travels have become now that I am able to speak the native language (or at least attempt to).
In the past in Italy, I have been excited to use my Italian. I think this was more of an excitement that came about because I was able to formulate a sentence than it was an excitement to have the key into the Italian culture. It wasn’t until I traveled to London that I realized how much of a barrier this lack of language in Italy created between the culture and me. While there, I was able to communicate completely. People even stopped and asked me for directions because they heard me speaking the country’s language. I have such fond memories of London and I think a large portion of this was the comfort I experienced due to communication. I was able to really taste the culture of London. These experiences and realizations have encouraged me to spend more time and effort practicing my Italian this past week. I have always known that it is important to know the language while in Italy (hence the reason we are taking an Italian course), but now I really can feel the importance.
The city where I practiced the most and seemed to get the most out of the experience was Siena. This town was nowhere near as touristy as say Venice or Florence, and therefore had far fewer English speakers. It was nice to be able to speak in Italian and have the locals speak back in Italian. In the touristy cities I often find myself discouraged because I am immediately marked as an English speaker. Whether they are irritated by my poor Italian or they are trying to convenience me because of their ability to speak both languages, it still takes away the opportunity that I could have to practice the language. By truly having the opportunity handed to me in Siena, I felt like I was more immersed into Italian culture then I have been at any other point since I arrived in Italy.
Communication is the foundation of a culture. It leads to relationships, the ability to read the news, and many other things. In Siena it gave me the opportunity to interact with locals and to feel as though I wasn't a burden to them. They did not have to change their lifestyle or their language, I had to change mine. It gave me a new outlook which is what the purpose of studying abroad is.
It was so enjoyable to hear what people in Siena had to say, but at the same time it was very challenging. Speaking to them made me realize just how far away I was and just how narrow minded I have become throughout my life. Having never traveled out of the country before, I had these preconceived notions of how difficult communicating would be. I was worried about reading signs and ordering in a restaurant. Once I arrived and realized how accommodating other countries were of English speakers, I almost instantly began to expect this ease everywhere that I went. Regardless of whether it was the idea that all signs would have the English translation, or that all store owners would speak English, I had my expectations fairly instantaneously upon my arrival to Europe.
Experiencing a small town such as Siena took me for a spin. I was not in the least bit disappointed by the lack of tourism or American comforts. Instead, I was so grateful. It opened up an entire new level of immersion that I am now striving to reach. The tiny sample of genuine communication has left me desiring to immerse myself more fully into the culture, something that I have been resistant to do so far in my journey.
In the past in Italy, I have been excited to use my Italian. I think this was more of an excitement that came about because I was able to formulate a sentence than it was an excitement to have the key into the Italian culture. It wasn’t until I traveled to London that I realized how much of a barrier this lack of language in Italy created between the culture and me. While there, I was able to communicate completely. People even stopped and asked me for directions because they heard me speaking the country’s language. I have such fond memories of London and I think a large portion of this was the comfort I experienced due to communication. I was able to really taste the culture of London. These experiences and realizations have encouraged me to spend more time and effort practicing my Italian this past week. I have always known that it is important to know the language while in Italy (hence the reason we are taking an Italian course), but now I really can feel the importance.
The city where I practiced the most and seemed to get the most out of the experience was Siena. This town was nowhere near as touristy as say Venice or Florence, and therefore had far fewer English speakers. It was nice to be able to speak in Italian and have the locals speak back in Italian. In the touristy cities I often find myself discouraged because I am immediately marked as an English speaker. Whether they are irritated by my poor Italian or they are trying to convenience me because of their ability to speak both languages, it still takes away the opportunity that I could have to practice the language. By truly having the opportunity handed to me in Siena, I felt like I was more immersed into Italian culture then I have been at any other point since I arrived in Italy.
Communication is the foundation of a culture. It leads to relationships, the ability to read the news, and many other things. In Siena it gave me the opportunity to interact with locals and to feel as though I wasn't a burden to them. They did not have to change their lifestyle or their language, I had to change mine. It gave me a new outlook which is what the purpose of studying abroad is.
It was so enjoyable to hear what people in Siena had to say, but at the same time it was very challenging. Speaking to them made me realize just how far away I was and just how narrow minded I have become throughout my life. Having never traveled out of the country before, I had these preconceived notions of how difficult communicating would be. I was worried about reading signs and ordering in a restaurant. Once I arrived and realized how accommodating other countries were of English speakers, I almost instantly began to expect this ease everywhere that I went. Regardless of whether it was the idea that all signs would have the English translation, or that all store owners would speak English, I had my expectations fairly instantaneously upon my arrival to Europe.
Experiencing a small town such as Siena took me for a spin. I was not in the least bit disappointed by the lack of tourism or American comforts. Instead, I was so grateful. It opened up an entire new level of immersion that I am now striving to reach. The tiny sample of genuine communication has left me desiring to immerse myself more fully into the culture, something that I have been resistant to do so far in my journey.
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Tour of Tintoretto's Last Suppers
On Tuesday, we were treated to a guided tour of Venice by Professor Gregory Dowling. This professor teaches here in Venice at Ca’ Foscari. He seemed to know just about everything there was to know about Venice. He had dedicated his morning to us in order to share his expert knowledge on Tintoretto’s Last Supper paintings which are scattered across the entire city. We spent the day heading in and out of many churches to analyze Tintoretto’s work. After hours of this tour, we ended at San Stefano for one last painting.
Although I could write an entire blog on the collection of paintings in itself, it is not what struck me the most about this morning. What I found to be the most beneficial was the walking aspect of the tour.
In Urry’s work Consuming Places, he spends a great deal of time explaining this idea of the tourist gaze. “The gaze is directed to features of landscape and townscape which separate them from everyday and routine experiences (Urry, Consuming Places, 132).” In many aspects, I still feel as though I am a tourist in Venice, and more importantly, a tourist who is guilty of this “gaze” that Urry speaks so much about. I find it more interesting to see those things which are different then what I am used to. The local grocery store in Venice is not nearly as intriguing as the bakery filled with traditional Venetian desserts. The inner tourist in me still stops to take pictures, look at the fish market, and stand in awe of the canals.
What I found so captivating about this walk that Professor Dowling led us on was how incredibly interesting the “normal” things in Venice were. These are things that would traditionally not ensnare the tourist gaze. Simple things such as a sign above a building, a plain bridge, or a tile in the sidewalk have so much meaning behind them which Professor Dowling shared.
Perhaps my favorite of these items was a small plaque above a window. This plaque was located in a small alley just off of Piazza San Marco in the side of an apartment building. Any tourist walking down the street would not stop to take a picture of this, and let’s be honest, probably wouldn’t even notice it. Professor Dowling told us that it represented the place where a woman threw a brick out of her first floor window (second floor in the United States), and in turn killed a man linked to the Venetian Revolution. Wow! Who would have known??
Professor Dowling helped me to even further see past the tourist façade of Venice. His knowledge about the little things in Venice, as well as his passion for sharing these, showed how much he as a person appreciated this city. It inspired me to look past the commonly touristic things and to begin to embrace the “normal” in Venice. As I’ve said before in my blogs, every week I can see a difference in the way I view this city. I find more respect and appreciation for it each and everyday. The whole theme of this course is to realize that the beauty of Venice is in the details, and how true I’m finding that statement to be!
Although I could write an entire blog on the collection of paintings in itself, it is not what struck me the most about this morning. What I found to be the most beneficial was the walking aspect of the tour.
In Urry’s work Consuming Places, he spends a great deal of time explaining this idea of the tourist gaze. “The gaze is directed to features of landscape and townscape which separate them from everyday and routine experiences (Urry, Consuming Places, 132).” In many aspects, I still feel as though I am a tourist in Venice, and more importantly, a tourist who is guilty of this “gaze” that Urry speaks so much about. I find it more interesting to see those things which are different then what I am used to. The local grocery store in Venice is not nearly as intriguing as the bakery filled with traditional Venetian desserts. The inner tourist in me still stops to take pictures, look at the fish market, and stand in awe of the canals.
What I found so captivating about this walk that Professor Dowling led us on was how incredibly interesting the “normal” things in Venice were. These are things that would traditionally not ensnare the tourist gaze. Simple things such as a sign above a building, a plain bridge, or a tile in the sidewalk have so much meaning behind them which Professor Dowling shared.
Perhaps my favorite of these items was a small plaque above a window. This plaque was located in a small alley just off of Piazza San Marco in the side of an apartment building. Any tourist walking down the street would not stop to take a picture of this, and let’s be honest, probably wouldn’t even notice it. Professor Dowling told us that it represented the place where a woman threw a brick out of her first floor window (second floor in the United States), and in turn killed a man linked to the Venetian Revolution. Wow! Who would have known??
Professor Dowling helped me to even further see past the tourist façade of Venice. His knowledge about the little things in Venice, as well as his passion for sharing these, showed how much he as a person appreciated this city. It inspired me to look past the commonly touristic things and to begin to embrace the “normal” in Venice. As I’ve said before in my blogs, every week I can see a difference in the way I view this city. I find more respect and appreciation for it each and everyday. The whole theme of this course is to realize that the beauty of Venice is in the details, and how true I’m finding that statement to be!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









